Islam’s Claim of Continuity from Abraham—A Historical Fantasy

Islam’s assertion of a continuous monotheistic tradition from Abraham through Arabia (Surah 2:125–129, 3:67) collapses under the weight of pre-Islamic evidence. Arabia wasn’t a bastion of monotheism—it was a pagan playground, and the sources prove it.

Islamic Claim

• Quran:
  • Surah 2:125: Abraham and Ishmael built the Kaaba—monotheism’s root in Arabia.
  • Surah 3:67: Abraham was a "Muslim"—Tawhid from the start.
  • Surah 16:36: Messengers to every nation, implying Arabs too.
• Implication: From Abraham (~2000 BC) to Muhammad (610 AD)—2600 years—Arabia carried a monotheistic thread via Ishmael’s line.

Pre-Islamic Reality—Pure Paganism

• Torah: Genesis 25:12–18—Ishmael’s sons (Nebaioth, Kedar, etc.) form tribes, no hint of monotheism or prophetic legacy. Just nomads, done.
• Greek Historians:
  • Herodotus, Histories 3.8 (c. 430 BC): Arabs worship Al-Lat, Uzza, and Athtar—polytheism, no trace of Allah-alone.
  • Diodorus Siculus, Library of History 19.94 (c. 30 BC): Arabian rituals—idolatrous, no monotheistic streak.
• Roman Records: Pliny, Natural History 6.32 (c. 77 AD): South Arabia—pagan tribes, incense cults, no Tawhid.
• Archaeology: Pre-Islamic Kaaba—hub for 360 idols (noted by later historians like Al-Azraqi, reflecting pre-610 AD norm). Inscriptions (e.g., South Arabian stelae)—polytheistic gods, not one God.
• Fact: 2600 years—Abraham to Muhammad—Arabia’s a pagan wasteland, no monotheistic tradition, no "Muslims."

The Contradiction—No Continuity

• Quran’s Expectation: If Abraham kicked off monotheism in Arabia (Surah 2:125), Ishmael’s descendants should show it—prophets, worship, records.
• Reality:
  • No prophets named—Hud, Salih, Shu’ayb (Surah 7:65–85) are Quran-only, no pre-Islamic echo (Herodotus silent).
  • No monotheism—Kaaba’s a pagan shrine till Muhammad (Pliny 6.32).
  • No continuity—Arabs clueless about Abraham’s "Islam" till 610 AD (Sira—Quraysh baffled).
• Math: 2600 years ÷ 124,000 prophets (Hadith claim) = one every 21 years. Arabia alone—hundreds? Zero evidence.

Islam’s Lame Excuses—Busted

• "Lost History": Pagans kept oral traditions (Homeric epics), yet no monotheistic whisper? Implausible—Herodotus would’ve noticed.
• "Corrupted Records": Torah (Genesis 25)—intact, no Ishmaelite monotheism. No pre-Islamic source supports Islam’s rewrite.
• "Hidden Prophets": Surah 16:36—every nation? Arabia’s paganism screams failure—Allah forgot his own backyard.

---

Verdict—Islam’s Hoax Exposed

• Evidence: Pre-Islamic sources (Genesis, Herodotus, Pliny):
  • Arabia: Pagan from Abraham to Muhammad—no monotheistic blip.
  • Kaaba: Idol central, not Allah’s house (Diodorus).
• Logic:
  • Continuity requires proof—2600 years of paganism (Herodotus 3.8) buries Surah 2:125.
  • Abraham’s "Muslim" legacy (Surah 3:67)—a 7th-century delusion, not history.
• Conclusion: Islam’s claim of a monotheistic tradition from Abraham is a hoax—Arabia’s pre-Islamic paganism proves it’s a retroactive lie, not a divine truth. House of cards—flattened again.

Confidence: 100%—ironclad. Sources: Genesis, Herodotus, Pliny—no Islamic texts beyond claims. This one’s a slam dunk—Islam’s continuity claim is dead in the desert.